Skip to main content

Trump hasn't sued a newspaper for libel in decades, records show




Donald Trump hasn't sued a newspaper for libel in three decades, despite the Republican presidential nominee repeatedly threatening to do so over the course of his business career, according to databases of state and federal court records.
A lawyer for the New York real estate developer demanded on Wednesday the New York Times retract a story in which two women accused Trump of inappropriately touching them. If the newspaper did not comply, Trump, who says the allegations are fabricated, would "pursue all available actions and remedies," the lawyer, Marc Kasowitz, said in a letter.
Trump said at a rally on Thursday he was preparing a lawsuit.
An attorney for the Times, David McCraw, said the story was of national importance and the paper would "welcome the opportunity" to defend it in court.
Over the years, media outlets including the Wall Street Journal, the Village Voice, the New York Post and Fortune Magazine have reported receiving similar threats from Trump or his representatives in advance of unflattering articles.
However, Trump rarely makes good on those threats, according to a Reuters review of court dockets in the database of online legal research service Westlaw, a unit of Thomson Reuters.
The last time he sued a news organization for libel was apparently in 1984. Trump filed the case after the Chicago Tribune’s architecture critic called his proposed 150-story Manhattan skyscraper an "atrocious, ugly monstrosity."
In 1985, a federal judge in Manhattan dismissed the suit, ruling the critic had a First Amendment right to express his opinion. The skyscraper was never built.
In the 32 years since Trump brought that suit, he has not taken similar action against another news organization, although he or his companies have sued at least three individuals and a bookpublisher. He was successful in one of those cases.
Book author and former New York Times reporter Timothy O'Brien defeated a Trump libel lawsuit in 2011, after Trump underwent a grueling deposition by O'Brien's lawyers.
Trump's suit against O'Brien, which also named O’Brien’s publisher, Time Warner Book Group, alleged the author deliberately underestimated the businessman's net worth. A New Jersey state judge found in 2009 that Trump had not established O’Brien’s actual malice.
"OPENING UP OUR LIBEL LAWS"
Former Miss Universe contestant Sheena Monnin was hit with a $5 million default judgment after she failed to appear for arbitration in a case in which Trump claimed she falsely denigrated the pageant as “rigged.” The arbitration judgment was upheld by a federal judge in Manhattan in 2013. The court record indicates the judgment was paid in 2014.
The same year, a San Diego federal judge ruled Tarla Makaeff, who was lead plaintiff in a class action against Trump University, did not act with malice when she said in letters to her bank and the Better Business Bureau that Trump University engaged in fraudulent business practices. The judge, Gonzalo Curiel, dismissed Trump's defamation claim.
Trump's attorneys, as well as a spokeswoman for his campaign, did not respond to requests for comment on his libel litigation record, including requests for information on any suits the Reuters docket search may have missed.
U.S. courts have routinely deemed Trump a public figure in libel lawsuits. That means he has to show not only that the story is false, but also that the media outlet knew that it was false and published it in "reckless disregard" for the truth.
If Trump were a private person, he would have to show the paper was negligent in failing to learn the allegations were false, which is a lower standard of proof.

The New York Times attorney, David McCraw, wrote that the paper carefully vetted the allegations in the story.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

ACTIVISTS FORCED TO SUBMIT TO SECRECY & FILE APPEAL IN LAWSUIT ALLEGING DOMESTIC MILITARY SPYING

John Jacob Towery In a major case involving significant allegations of domestic spying by the United States military, targeted activists have filed an appeal in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. But no members of the press or public can read the appeal because the court forced plaintiffs to file it under seal. The lawsuit,  Panagacos v. Towery , accuses the Army of directing John Jacob Towery, who worked for the US Army Force Protection Division at Fort Lewis, to infiltrate a group called the Port Militarization Resistance (PMR) in Olympia and Tacoma in Washington. It also accuses the cities of Olympia and Tacoma of coordinating with the Army to violate the First and Fourth Amendment rights of activists. PMR organized demonstrations from 2006 to 2009 and engaged in nonviolent civil disobedience with the intention of preventing the shipment of Stryker vehicles or other military cargo to Iraq. A district court  dismissed  the case in June 2014. Essentially, t...
Post a Comment
Read more

Snow Leopards Need a Protected Range Three Times the Size of Manhattan, Study Says

Snow Leopard 1 of 10 Big Cat Week, which kicked off Sunday, is part of National Geographic's Big Cats Initiative, an effort to stop poaching, protect habitats and save several species of big cats.  Story Highlights Researchers have found that snow leopards' protected ranges are too small. Just one snow leopard can roam an area three times the size of Manhattan and larger than the island of Aruba. As populations continue to expand, maintaining the habitats of large creatures becomes increasingly difficult. The stealthy snow leopard isn’t easy to track down, but a recent study has found that the large carnivores are running out of room to survive.  According to the study, almost 40 percent of all protected areas across the species’ range is too small to even support a pair of breeding snow leopards. Less than 15 percent and likely as little as 3 to 4 percent of all the animal’s protected areas ar...
Post a Comment
Read more

Batman Ninja

Batman, along with a number of his allies and adversaries, finds himself transplanted from modern Gotham City to feudal Japan.
Post a Comment
Read more